Skip to content
Thousand Rivers Partners
Language: EN
Contact us

When a mining licence overlaps a plantation

Why mining licences and plantation titles overlap in Kalimantan, what Indonesian law says about land rights above a mine and how to check for an overlap.

5 min read

In Kalimantan the same ground can carry two permits: a mining licence for what lies under it and a plantation licence or land title for what grows on it. Neither holder necessarily did anything wrong. The permits were issued by different offices, on different maps, often years apart.

For an investor the question is simple. If you buy into either business, can the other one stop you? Overlaps are common enough that every deal for a mine, an estate or a land bank should check for them.

How overlaps happen

Until the mid-2010s, district heads issued most mining licences, and regencies also issued plantation location permits. Maps were poor, coordinates were wrong and offices didn’t share records. Coal licences describes how thousands of licences were issued and later sorted into those that were clean and clear and those that weren’t.

Since 2020 mining licences for metals and coal have been issued by the central government through the online system. That doesn’t remove old overlaps. Plantation titles issued decades ago and mining licences issued in the 2000s still sit on the same ground.

Reported cases include West Kalimantan, where the provincial government revoked 116 mining licences in 2015 after a review coordinated with the anti-corruption commission, with overlaps with other sectors, plantations among them, one of the problems. Overlaps with plantations have also been reported in East Kalimantan. Treat these as a sign of how widespread the problem was, not as a count of what exists today.

What the law says

Indonesian law separates what’s under the ground from what’s on it. Under the Mining Law (Law 4 of 2009, as amended), as the original text reads:

  • A mining area right doesn’t include a right to the land’s surface (Article 134).
  • An exploration licence holder can work only after the holder of the land right agrees (Article 135).
  • A holder must settle land rights before starting production, and may do so in stages as it needs the land (Article 136).
  • A mining licence isn’t ownership of the land (Article 138).

Later laws amended the Mining Law, among them Law 3 of 2020 and Law 2 of 2025, so the current wording of each article should be checked with a lawyer. Law 3 of 2020 added an article under which the central government resolves land-rights problems for mining.

The practical result is that a mining licence doesn’t let the miner dig under a plantation by itself. The miner has to reach terms with whoever holds the land right, which in a plantation is usually the company with the right to cultivate (HGU), covered in plantation permits and HGU. In practice that means buying the land, leasing it or paying compensation. Terms are negotiated case by case, and the landholder has no duty to accept an offer it finds too low.

The reverse also holds. A plantation title doesn’t give the estate the minerals below.

The overlap rule for mining licences

Law 2 of 2025 added a rule for old licences. Under its Article 171B, a mining licence issued before the law that overlaps another mining area or licence is revoked after the government’s evaluation, and the area returns to the state. The government was to set the detail in a regulation. Reports on the law describe overlaps between mining licences. The article text found for this review doesn’t name plantations, so don’t assume it solves a plantation overlap. Coal concession due diligence and buying into a gold IUP both explain why a licence overlap now threatens the licence itself.

Forest status as the third layer

Many overlaps also involve forest land. A plantation inside a forest area without release, or a mine without a forest-use approval, adds a third problem on top of the other two. Forest area status explains how to check it, and the same overlay should include the forest map.

How to check for an overlap

  1. Get the coordinates. For a mining licence, use the licence record and the map attached to it. For a plantation, use the HGU certificate and its measured map. For land, use the certificate’s survey data.
  2. Plot them on one map. A surveyor or a mining lawyer can overlay the licence area, the HGU, any other certificates and the forest map. Do the whole area, not a sample.
  3. Compare with the ministry’s records. Check the licence number, holder, commodity, stage and area against the official mining data system rather than a copy from the seller.
  4. Ask the land office. The land office can confirm which titles cover the area, and whether any are disputed.
  5. Walk the ground. A map can hide a plantation block, a village or an old road. Visit the area and talk to the people who work there.
  6. Ask for written agreements. If the miner already uses plantation land, ask for the land deal. If an estate sits above a deposit, ask whether the licence holder has settled terms with it.

If there is an overlap

Overlaps aren’t always deal-breakers. Some are small, and some are already settled.

  • A small overlap can be removed by adjusting the plan. The pit or the planting simply avoids the strip.
  • A settled overlap should be backed by a signed agreement and proof that payments were made. The deal should include a copy.
  • A large or unsettled overlap is a risk to price in, or a reason to walk away. A mine that can’t reach its ore, or an estate with a pit in the middle, is worth less than its licences suggest.
  • A disputed overlap that has reached a court or a government complaint can freeze both sides for years. Check the Supreme Court’s public directory of decisions for the parties’ names.

Make clearing the overlap a condition of the purchase, and keep the right to withdraw if the check turns up something the seller didn’t disclose. Buying an existing plantation covers the estate side of the same checks.

General information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules change, so confirm the current regulation with a notary or lawyer before you act.