Resolving business disputes in Indonesia
How business disputes are settled in Indonesia: the courts, mediation, BANI and SIAC arbitration, and how a foreign arbitral award is enforced against assets there.
6 min read
A foreign investor in a Kalimantan project will usually have contracts with Indonesian parties: a seller, a local partner, a contractor, a buyer of the output. If one of those deals goes wrong, the question isn’t only who is right. It’s where the dispute will be heard, how long it will take and whether the result can be enforced against assets in Indonesia.
Those answers are mostly set by the dispute clause signed at the start. This article covers the main routes as of 2026. It’s general information, not legal advice, and an Indonesian lawyer should review any dispute clause before signing.
The courts
Indonesia’s general courts start at the district court (Pengadilan Negeri), with appeals to the high court (Pengadilan Tinggi) and then to the Supreme Court (Mahkamah Agung) on points of law, called cassation. After that, a party can still ask the Supreme Court for a case review (Peninjauan Kembali) on narrow grounds, such as new evidence. Bankruptcy and suspension of debt payments go to the commercial courts, which sit inside five district courts, and challenges to government decisions, including land certificates, go to the State Administrative Court (Pengadilan Tata Usaha Negara, PTUN).
Kalimantan’s provincial capitals and most districts have their own district court. Proceedings are in Indonesian, judges decide without juries and there’s no discovery of documents of the kind found in common law countries. A commercial case that goes through appeal and cassation can take several years, and a case review can come later still.
Before a civil case is heard, the court requires the parties to try mediation, under Supreme Court Regulation 1 of 2016. A judge or a certified mediator runs it, and a settlement reached there can be made into a court deed that’s enforceable like a judgment. Many cases do settle at this stage.
Foreign court judgments don’t travel
A judgment from a court in Singapore, London or Hong Kong generally can’t be enforced in Indonesia. Indonesia has no treaty for recognising foreign court judgments, and the old civil procedure rules say the case has to be heard again in an Indonesian court, where the foreign judgment counts only as evidence.
That’s the main reason contracts with Indonesian parties so often choose arbitration. If the other side’s assets are in Kalimantan, a foreign court judgment may be of little practical use.
Arbitration
Arbitration is governed by Law 30 of 1999 on Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution. The parties have to agree to it in writing, either in the contract or after the dispute arises. Once they have, the courts must decline to hear the case.
The main domestic body is the Indonesian National Board of Arbitration (Badan Arbitrase Nasional Indonesia, BANI). Its rules allow foreign arbitrators and English proceedings if the parties agree. The BANI name has been the subject of a dispute between two bodies, so a clause should name the institution and its address precisely. An award made in Indonesia has to be registered with the district court within 30 days of being issued before it can be enforced.
For international contracts, many parties choose the Singapore International Arbitration Centre (SIAC), with Singapore as the seat. Others use the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) or the Hong Kong International Arbitration Centre (HKIAC). An award made in Singapore is a foreign award in Indonesia, so it goes through the recognition process below.
Under the Arbitration Law, an award can be annulled only on narrow grounds, such as forged documents, documents hidden by a party or fraud, and only by the court of the place where it was made. In practice, Indonesian courts have sometimes been asked to set aside foreign awards anyway, which is one more reason to keep the clause clean.
Enforcing a foreign award
Indonesia joined the New York Convention on the recognition of foreign arbitral awards in 1981, so awards made in other member countries can be enforced. The process runs through the Central Jakarta District Court, which issues an order of enforcement (exequatur) after the award is registered there. If the Indonesian state is a party, the Supreme Court handles it instead.
The court checks a short list of conditions. The award has to come from a country that’s also a member of the Convention, it has to concern a matter of commercial law under Indonesian law, and it must not conflict with public order. Public order has been read broadly in some past cases, which is the main source of uncertainty. Once the exequatur is granted, enforcement against assets goes through the district court where those assets are, often in Kalimantan, which adds time.
The language of the contract
Law 24 of 2009 requires agreements involving an Indonesian party to be made in Indonesian, and Presidential Regulation 63 of 2019 adds that a foreign language version can sit alongside it. In 2015, the Supreme Court upheld a decision that voided a loan agreement written only in English for breaching that rule. Since then, the usual practice is a bilingual contract with a clause saying which version prevails, and a well-drafted dispute clause in both languages.
Choosing the route
Arbitration is usually preferred for contracts with an Indonesian counterparty because the award can be enforced and the hearing can be kept private, in English and in front of arbitrators who know the industry. Its costs are higher, especially at a foreign institution, and enforcement still needs the Indonesian courts at the end.
Courts can make sense for smaller claims, for disputes over land, which Indonesian courts and agencies decide in any case, and where speed of an injunction-type order matters more than neutrality. Disputes over land title and customary claims often need the land agency or local mediation first, as covered in customary land and communities.
For joint ventures, the dispute clause sits inside the shareholder agreement. How that agreement is put together is covered in working with a local partner, and the deadlock and exit terms usually decide how a dispute plays out long before anyone files a claim. The same points apply to gold project partnerships.
What to check first
- The dispute clause in every main contract: the institution, the seat, the language, the number of arbitrators and the governing law.
- That the contract exists in Indonesian as well as English, with a clause saying which version prevails.
- Where the counterparty’s assets are, and whether an award or judgment could reach them.
- Whether a contract you’re taking over in an acquisition already names a court or an institution, and whether that suits you.
- A budget and a timeline that allow for enforcement in Indonesia, not just the hearing.
- The mediation step, which is often the fastest and cheapest way out.
General information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules change, so confirm the current regulation with a notary or lawyer before you act.