Working with a local partner in Indonesia
Choosing an Indonesian partner, checking them first, and structuring the deal: shareholder agreements, articles of association, foreign ownership limits and exits.
6 min read
Many foreign investors in Kalimantan go in with a local partner. Sometimes the law asks for one, where a business line caps foreign ownership. More often the partner brings what the foreigner lacks: the land, the licence, the relationships with villages and local government, and the people who know how an estate or a mine actually runs.
A good partner can make a project possible. A poorly chosen one, or a good one under a weak agreement, is one of the most common reasons foreign investments in Indonesia fail. This article covers how to choose one and how the deal is usually built.
Why a partner, and what kind
Start with what the partner is for. The answer decides how the deal should be shaped.
- A partner who holds the asset, such as land, an estate’s right to cultivate or a mining licence, is usually selling or contributing it, and the main risk is the asset itself.
- A partner who brings operating skill, such as a contractor or an experienced estate manager, may be better paid under a contract than given shares.
- A partner needed to meet a foreign ownership cap is a legal requirement, and the structure has to respect the cap for real, not on paper only.
- A partner who brings relationships with officials or communities needs the closest look, because that value is hard to measure and easy to overstate.
Some sectors carry partnership rules of their own. Plantation companies must build smallholder plots for nearby communities, as set out in smallholders and plasma schemes, and some business lines open to foreigners only on condition of a partnership with local small businesses or cooperatives.
Checking the partner first
Do the same checks on the partner that you’d do on the asset. In Indonesia that usually means:
- the company’s record at the Ministry of Law’s company registry (Administrasi Hukum Umum, AHU): its deed of establishment, every later amendment, its shareholders, directors and commissioners, and its declared beneficial owners
- searches of the district court records for lawsuits and bankruptcy filings, both against the company and against the people behind it
- its tax status, and whether it has filed its tax returns and investment reports
- whether the licences and land titles it says it holds are real, current and in its own name, which for land means checking the certificate at the land office
- whether any of its owners are officials, family of officials or politically exposed, which raises corruption risk under Indonesian law and under the foreign laws that may apply to you
- its reputation with banks, buyers, contractors and the communities around its sites
Ask for the papers, then check them against the registries yourself or through a lawyer. Copies can be out of date, and in some cases they’re simply wrong.
Structuring the company
Most partnerships with a foreign investor take the form of a foreign-owned company (PT PMA), set up as described in setting up a PT PMA. The foreign share has to stay within whatever cap applies to each business line, as listed in which sectors foreign investors can enter.
Two documents govern the partnership. The articles of association are part of the notarial deed of the company, are approved by the Ministry of Law and bind everyone. The shareholder agreement is a private contract between the shareholders.
Indonesian courts and notaries look first at the articles of association. If the shareholder agreement says one thing and the articles say another, the articles usually win in practice. So the main protections for a minority foreign investor have to be written into the articles as far as the Company Law (Law 40 of 2007) allows, not only into the shareholder agreement.
The terms that usually matter most are:
- who appoints the directors and commissioners, and how many each side gets
- reserved matters that need both sides to agree, such as new debt, selling assets, related party deals and changes to the business plan
- how deadlocks are broken
- rights of first refusal, which the Company Law already gives existing shareholders in part, and tag-along and drag-along rights on a sale
- what happens if one side doesn’t fund its share of new capital
- how and where disputes are settled, covered in resolving business disputes
Signatures on bank accounts and the company’s seal of authority matter as much as the share split. A local director who controls the bank account and the relationship with the licensing office has real control, whatever the shareholding says.
Limits the law sets
The Investment Law (Law 25 of 2007) voids any agreement under which shares are held in one person’s name for someone else. That rules out the arrangement where a local partner holds shares above a foreign ownership cap as a nominee for the foreign investor. Side agreements, powers of attorney and pledges that try to give the foreigner control over those shares carry the same risk. If the arrangement is tested, the foreigner may have no claim to the shares or the asset. The details are in nominee arrangements and their risks.
Land titles have limits too. A PT PMA can hold the right to build (Hak Guna Bangunan, HGB), the right to cultivate (Hak Guna Usaha, HGU) or the right of use (Hak Pakai), but not freehold (Hak Milik). A partner who keeps freehold land in their own name and lets the company use it under a lease leaves the company exposed if the relationship sours.
If the partner contributes land or a licence in exchange for shares, the contribution has to be valued, and some licences can’t be transferred at all without the regulator’s approval. Check that before agreeing the split.
Exits
Plan the exit at the start. Most partnerships end in one of a few ways: one side buys the other out, both sell to a third party, or the company is wound up. The agreement should set how a price is set, who can force a sale and when. A transfer of shares in a PT PMA needs the shareholders’ approval and updates to the company’s records with the Ministry of Law and in the Online Single Submission system (OSS), and a change of control of a plantation or mining company may need the sector ministry’s approval as well.
What to check first
- What exactly the partner brings, and whether a contract would serve better than shares.
- The partner’s company records, court records and beneficial owners, checked against the registries, not just copies.
- Whether the assets the partner is bringing are held in the partner’s name, on a title the company can hold.
- That the articles of association carry the protections in the shareholder agreement.
- Who controls the bank accounts and the licence filings day to day.
- How either side can leave, and at what price.
General information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules change, so confirm the current regulation with a notary or lawyer before you act.