Benefit sharing and community consent in carbon projects
Why communities make or break a carbon project in Kalimantan: consent, customary land, sharing credit revenue and handling complaints before they become disputes.
5 min read
A carbon project asks the people who live in or near a forest, a peat dome or a mangrove coast to change how they use it, often for thirty years or more. If they don’t agree, or stop agreeing, the project can’t deliver. Fires get lit, trees get cut, and buyers who read the news walk away.
So community terms aren’t a side issue. They decide whether the carbon is real over the life of the project, and they’re one of the first things a serious buyer checks.
Who the community is
In Kalimantan the people around a project site are rarely one group. There may be Dayak or Malay customary communities with claims that go back generations, villages with an elected head and a village government, migrant farmers who arrived with plantations or transmigration schemes, and families who fish, tap rubber or collect forest products without any title.
Each holds a different kind of right. Customary communities hold land collectively under their own law, a right Indonesian law recognises only through a formal process many haven’t finished. The article on customary land and community consent explains how that recognition works. Villages have their own budget and legal standing. Users without papers still lose income if a project closes off their land.
A project that deals only with the village head, or only with the loudest group, builds its consent on part of the people it affects.
Free, prior and informed consent
International standards expect free, prior and informed consent (FPIC) from the people whose rights or livelihoods a project touches. In plain terms:
- Free: no pressure, no payments made to win a vote, no officials or police in the room to push it through.
- Prior: before the permit application, the land deals or the project design are final, and with enough time to discuss it inside the community.
- Informed: people have seen the map, the length of the project, what they can and can’t do on the land, how much money is involved and where it goes, in a language and form they understand.
- Consent: the community can say no, and a no is respected.
Consent is a process, not a single signature. It’s normally renewed at key points: when the design changes, when the first credits are sold and when the benefit formula is reviewed. Standards and buyers want to see the record: meeting notes, attendance lists, maps people marked up and the agreements signed by the bodies the community itself chose.
Indonesian law has its own consent duties. The Plantation Law and the forestry rules require deliberation (musyawarah) with customary communities before their land is used. The carbon rules also ask projects to show they’ve dealt with the people affected. The details depend on the permit type, so check them for your project.
How projects share benefits
Benefit sharing means the community gets a defined part of what the project earns. There’s no single formula, and as of 2026 the national rules set principles rather than fixed shares for most project types. Common elements include:
- A share of revenue from each credit sale, paid to a village body, a cooperative or a customary institution under a written formula.
- Paid work in patrols, fire crews, nursery work, planting and monitoring.
- Funding for village programmes the community chooses: water, schools, clinics, small loans, farm support.
- Support for livelihoods that don’t need clearing, such as agroforestry, rubber, fisheries or honey.
- Help getting legal recognition of customary land or a social forestry permit.
Two questions matter more than the headline share. First, is it a share of gross revenue or of profit? A profit share can shrink to nothing once the developer’s costs are counted. Second, who in the community receives it, and how do they decide how it’s spent? Money paid to a body that people don’t trust often makes conflict worse.
When the community holds the permit
Some projects sit on land where a community already holds rights under social forestry (perhutanan sosial): a village forest (hutan desa), community forestry (hutan kemasyarakatan), a partnership with a forest permit holder, or a recognised customary forest. In those cases the community, or its village body or cooperative, is the permit holder, and an outside investor works with them under a contract.
That turns the usual structure around. The investor brings money, technical work and access to buyers. The community holds the land rights. The contract has to set out who owns the credits, how revenue is split, who pays for verification and what happens if either side wants to leave. Forestry ministry rules govern what such holders can agree to, so check them early. The permits themselves are covered in carbon project licences.
Grievances
Every project will get complaints: about boundaries, about who was paid, about patrols stopping someone from collecting firewood, about promises people remember differently. A project needs a way to hear them before they turn into blockades or petitions to a standard body.
A grievance process that works usually has:
- More than one way in, including one that doesn’t go through the village head.
- A written log of every complaint, the response and the time it took.
- A person or committee with authority to fix things, not just to receive them.
- A route to someone independent if the complainant isn’t satisfied.
Ask to see the log. A project with no recorded complaints is more likely hiding them than free of them.
What to check
- Ask for the stakeholder map: every village, customary community and user group in and around the project, and how each was involved.
- Ask for the consent record and read it. Check dates against the permit application and project start.
- Ask for the benefit sharing agreement, the formula and what has actually been paid so far, with receipts.
- Visit without the developer. Talk to the customary head, women’s groups and families along the boundary, not only the village government.
- Ask for the grievance log and any complaints to the standard, the ministry or the press.
- Check for overlaps with other permits or customary claims, especially on peat. See peatland restoration projects and forest carbon and REDD+ for the site-specific issues.
General information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules change, so confirm the current regulation with a notary or lawyer before you act.