What to check before investing in a carbon project
A due diligence list for carbon projects in Kalimantan: land and permits, the baseline, leakage, permanence and buffers, offtake terms and changing rules.
5 min read
A carbon project sells a promise that something will or won’t happen to a piece of land for decades. Its value rests on paperwork, measurement and the behaviour of people nearby, more than on any physical asset you can inspect.
That makes due diligence different from buying an estate or a mine. Much of it is about whether the numbers behind the credits will hold up when a buyer, a journalist or a regulator looks at them. This checklist covers the main points for projects in Kalimantan, whether forest, peat or mangrove.
Land and permits
Start where every Kalimantan deal starts: who controls the ground.
- Check the forest area status of every part of the project. Inside the forest estate (kawasan hutan), a carbon project needs a permit from the forestry ministry, usually a forest utilisation business permit (Perizinan Berusaha Pemanfaatan Hutan, PBPH) for ecosystem restoration or carbon, or a social forestry approval held by a community. Outside it, in other-use areas (areal penggunaan lain, APL), the project needs the land rights of whoever holds the titles. Forest area status explains how to check.
- Get the permit itself, its map, its term and its conditions. Check the holder is the company you’re investing in, and that the permit allows carbon activities.
- Overlay the project map on every other permit you can find: plantations, mining licences, timber concessions, village land and customary claims. Overlaps are common, and a mining licence under a forest project is a serious problem.
- Check the permit is in good standing: fees paid, reports filed, no warning letters.
The baseline
The baseline is the scenario the project compares itself with: how much forest would have been lost, how much peat would have burned, how many ponds would have been dug. Every credit is the gap between that and what actually happened, so a baseline set too high produces credits that don’t reflect real reductions.
Questions to ask:
- What method set the baseline, and what reference area or historical period did it use?
- Was the threat real? Was there a plantation permit, a road, a logging plan or a record of clearing nearby?
- Has the baseline been updated as the methodology requires, and did the update cut credit volumes?
- Has anyone outside the project studied it? Several large forest projects worldwide have been criticised for inflated baselines, and buyers now check.
Additionality is linked: would the protection have happened anyway? A forest in a national park, or peat that the law already protects from new clearing, may not need a carbon project to stay standing.
Leakage
Leakage is when the project stops clearing in one place and the clearing moves somewhere else. A plantation company that can’t clear a block may clear another one. Villagers who can’t farm inside the project may farm just outside it.
Methodologies make projects estimate leakage and deduct it from their credits. Check the deduction and the area monitored for it, and ask whether activities that were displaced can be traced.
Permanence and the buffer
Forest and peat carbon can be released later by fire, illegal logging, a change of government policy or a new permit over the same land. In Kalimantan, fire on drained peat is the obvious risk, as peat and fire explains for estates.
Standards handle this with a buffer pool: a share of every issuance is set aside to cover future losses. Ask:
- What percentage goes to the buffer, and how was the risk score calculated?
- Has the project had fires, encroachment or other losses, and were buffer credits cancelled to cover them?
- How long is the project committed to monitoring after the last credit is issued?
Community and benefit sharing
A project without the support of the people around it is a project at risk of losing its carbon. Read the consent record, the benefit sharing agreement and the grievance log, and visit the villages without the developer. Benefit sharing and community consent covers what good looks like.
Credits, registry and offtake
- Ask for the issuance record in every registry the project uses, with serial numbers. Check how many credits have been issued, sold, retired and are still in stock.
- Check whether the project is recorded in Indonesia’s national registry, and whether any credits are authorised for international transfer with a corresponding adjustment. Verification and the registry explains why that matters.
- Read the offtake contracts. Who buys, at what price, for how many years, and what happens if issuance falls short? A forward sale at a fixed price protects revenue but can force the project to buy credits elsewhere if its own come in low.
- Look at past sales. A project that has sold little of what it issued may have a quality problem, not just a marketing one.
Costs and cash flow
Carbon projects spend heavily up front: permits, baseline studies, community work, patrols, fire crews, nurseries and the first validation. Credits come later, after the first monitoring period and verification. Model the gap.
Running costs don’t stop, and verification has to be paid for every cycle. Check what share of revenue goes to the community, the permit holder, the developer and the standard, and what’s left for investors after that.
Rules that can change
Indonesia’s carbon rules have shifted several times since 2021. The carbon pricing regulation was replaced in 2025, the agencies responsible were reorganised when the environment and forestry ministry split in 2024, and the rules on international sales have tightened and loosened. More changes are likely.
Ask how the project’s contracts handle a change in law: who bears the cost if credits can no longer be exported, if the government takes a larger share or if a registry step is added. The carbon market overview describes the frame as of 2026.
Where to start
Ask for these first, in this order:
- The permit, its map and an overlay against every other permit and claim.
- The project design document, the latest monitoring report and the verification reports.
- The registry records: issuance, buffer, retirements and stock.
- The offtake contracts and the benefit sharing agreement, with payment records.
- A site visit in the dry season, with time to talk to the villages alone.
Any gap in the first two is reason enough to stop.
General information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules change, so confirm the current regulation with a notary or lawyer before you act.