Coal quality: calorific value, GAR and NAR, ash and sulphur
The measures that set a coal's price: calorific value on GAR, NAR and other bases, moisture, ash and sulphur, and why most Kalimantan coal is lower rank.
6 min read
Coal is sold by its quality, not just its weight. Two cargoes of the same tonnage can differ in price by a wide margin because one gives off more heat, carries less water or leaves less ash. A coal deposit’s value starts with its quality data, and reading that data means knowing which basis each number is reported on.
For Kalimantan, quality also explains the business. Most of the island’s coal is young and wet, which shapes who buys it, how far it can travel and how it’s priced.
Calorific value
The calorific value is the heat a coal releases when it burns, in kilocalories per kilogram (kcal/kg). It’s the main driver of price. Indonesia’s coal reference price (Harga Batubara Acuan, HBA) is set for four calorific bands, at 6,322, 5,300, 4,100 and 3,400 kcal/kg on a gross as-received basis, and contract prices usually move in proportion to the calorific value actually delivered. The article on how Indonesian coal is priced explains the mechanics.
The same coal can be described by several different numbers depending on the basis of measurement. Mixing them up is one of the easiest mistakes to make in a coal deal.
GAR, NAR and the other bases
Coal contains water, and how much water is counted changes the reported calorific value.
- As received (ar) measures the coal as it’s delivered, with all its moisture. Gross as received (GAR) is the basis most Indonesian sellers and the HBA use.
- Air dried (adb) measures the coal after surface water has dried off in the laboratory, leaving only the moisture held inside the coal. Exploration reports and geological surveys often use it.
- Dry basis (db) removes all the water, and dry ash free (daf) removes the ash as well. These are used to compare coals for science rather than for sale.
Gross and net calorific value differ too. Gross value counts all the heat, including the heat used to turn the coal’s water and hydrogen into steam. Net value subtracts that heat, since a boiler can’t use it. Net as received (NAR) is common in some buyer markets, including parts of the Chinese and Indian trade.
NAR is always lower than GAR for the same coal, and the gap grows as moisture rises. For wet, low-rank coal it’s large. A figure of 5,000 kcal/kg that turns out to be on an air-dried basis can be well under that as received. When a seller quotes a calorific value, always ask on what basis, and convert everything to the basis in the sales contract before comparing.
Moisture
Moisture comes in two forms. Inherent moisture is held in the coal’s structure and stays even after surface drying. Total moisture adds the surface water picked up from rain, washing or storage. Total moisture is what the buyer pays for and what the ship carries.
Wet coal costs more to move per unit of heat. A tonne of high-moisture coal sells for less but costs about the same to truck, barge and load, so moisture eats into the margin at every step. That’s why remote deposits of wet coal struggle to cover their logistics, as hauling, barging and ports explains. Contracts usually set a maximum total moisture, with a price penalty or rejection above it.
Kalimantan’s rainfall adds surface moisture on stockpiles, haul roads and barges. Covered or well-drained stockpiles and short stockpile times help.
Ash and sulphur
Ash is what’s left after burning: the mineral matter in the coal. High ash lowers the calorific value, wears boilers and costs the power plant money to dispose of. Low ash is one of Kalimantan coal’s selling points, and many of its coals have ash contents well below those of coal from some other exporters.
Sulphur turns into sulphur dioxide when coal burns, and power plants face emission limits on it. Buyers with tight limits pay more for low-sulphur coal or blend it with higher-sulphur supply. Much Kalimantan coal is low in sulphur, but some seams are not, so check by seam.
Both are quoted on a stated basis too, usually air dried. Contracts set typical values and rejection limits for each.
Other measures buyers check
A full specification usually covers more than calorific value, moisture, ash and sulphur:
- Volatile matter and fixed carbon, from the proximate analysis, which affect how coal ignites and burns.
- The Hardgrove grindability index (HGI), which shows how easily coal can be milled into the fine powder power plants burn. Some low-rank coals are hard to grind.
- Ash fusion temperatures, which show whether the ash will melt and stick inside the boiler.
- Size, the share of fines and lumps.
Metallurgical coal for steelmaking is judged on different properties, such as how it behaves when turned into coke. Very little Kalimantan coal falls in that category.
Why Kalimantan coal is mostly lower rank
Coal forms from buried plant matter that slowly loses water and gains carbon under heat and pressure. The further that process goes, the higher the rank: lignite at the bottom, then sub-bituminous, bituminous and anthracite. Higher rank means more carbon, less moisture and more heat per kilogram.
Most of Kalimantan’s coal is geologically young, laid down in basins such as the Kutai, Barito and Tarakan. It hasn’t been buried as long or as deeply as older coals elsewhere, so much of it is sub-bituminous or lignite: high in moisture, moderate in calorific value, often low in ash and sulphur. The Geological Agency classes about two-thirds of Indonesia’s coal resources as low-calorie coal. A few deposits in East and South Kalimantan produce higher-value coal, and parts of Central Kalimantan hold metallurgical coal, but they’re the minority.
Low-rank coal also tends to heat up and catch fire on its own in stockpiles and ship holds if stored too long or compacted badly. Mines and shippers manage this with stockpile design, temperature checks and short storage times.
Low rank isn’t a defect. It suits many power plants in China, India and Southeast Asia that were designed for it, and it’s one reason Indonesian coal is so widely traded. It does limit the price per tonne and the distance the coal can travel profitably. It’s also part of why the government promotes coal downstreaming, which aims to turn low-rank coal into products of higher value.
How quality is checked
Quality data comes from three places. Exploration drilling gives seam-by-seam analyses that feed the resource model. The mine’s own laboratory tests coal as it’s produced. And at loading, an independent surveyor samples the cargo and issues a certificate of sampling and analysis, which usually sets the price under the contract and the royalty paid to the state.
The three should broadly agree. Where the surveyor’s figures at the port are consistently below the mine’s own, the reported quality of the reserves may be too optimistic.
What to ask for
Before you rely on a coal deposit’s quality, ask for these:
- Laboratory analyses by seam from the exploration drilling, with the basis stated for every figure.
- The coal quality model used in the resource and reserve estimate, and the laboratory that did the work.
- Surveyor certificates for recent shipments, with total moisture, calorific value (GAR and, if relevant, NAR), ash and sulphur.
- A reconciliation of the mine’s own lab results with the surveyor’s certificates over at least a year.
- Any blending the mine does to meet its contracts, and which seams it relies on.
Then compare each figure on the same basis as the sales contract. The checks on the rest of a concession are in coal concession due diligence.
General information, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules change, so confirm the current regulation with a notary or lawyer before you act.